Feb. 10th, 2025

matsushima: before you: a blessing and a curse (🧿🧿🧿)
[personal profile] matsushima
I will (probably) post more analysis of content and style when I've finished this book but I wanted to say that twice now, two chapters in, I've encountered words I've never seen before and could not figure out from context.
    recherché adj. rare, exotic, or obscure.
    métier n. a profession or occupation.
I'm not against learning new words but it does vibe with my general sense that this book is a bit… overwritten? it's really flowery and occasionally jargony in a way that I think limits the readership of a book that really ought to be read to anyone who's concerned about the fact that the U.S. is going to hell in a hand basket and how we got here.
I would like to recommend this to, e.g., my mother, who thinks of herself (incorrectly and unfairly) as a person who is "not smart." (She has a Masters of Arts in Education and she's a 2nd dan black belt and she reads all of the time and plays, like, five instruments and she's a poet and singer-songwriter so it's obviously not true that she is "not smart.") I think she will feel a little overwhelmed and off-put by the writerliness of it all and that's too bad because I know she wants to understand what's going on in the U.S. because she lives there and is a person who is concerned about the wellbeing of others. (My mom is also someone who is fundamentally so good at heart that she simply cannot comprehend why someone would do something to harm someone else. It's genuinely baffling for her - which I think contributes to her sense of being "not smart.")
Personally, I'm finding it a bit hard to follow. I'd like to think I'm "smart" enough (but honestly I'm just a A+ bullshitter) but I also have chronic fatigue and, lately, pretty bad brain fog and it's really a slog for me right now even tho this is a subject I know a bit about and am interested in learning more. So it's not like I got thrown into the subject deep end without a floatie or like I'm trying to read something I'm bored by but I keep losing track of what Talia Lavin's trying to say.

P.S. 99% my mom will never see this but if she does: hi, mom! You are smart! You're just not bitter and jaded like I am and Dad was!

Profile

pineisland: (Default)
pine island projects

June 2025

S M T W T F S
1234567
8 91011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930     
Page generated Jun. 9th, 2025 01:45 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios